Advertisment

Balanced Crystalloids vs Saline in ICU: A Review on In-Hospital Mortality Rates

author-image
Mason Walker
New Update
NULL

Balanced Crystalloids vs Saline in ICU: A Review on In-Hospital Mortality Rates

Advertisment

Understanding Balanced Crystalloids

Advertisment

In the realm of intensive care medicine, the use of intravenous fluids is a common practice and a crucial part of patient management. One of the main debates in this context has been the choice of fluid – balanced crystalloids or saline. Balanced crystalloids have a composition that closely resembles the body's own fluid constitution and are believed to provide a more physiological approach to fluid therapy.

Recent Review in The Lancet Respiratory Medicine

A recent review published in The Lancet Respiratory Medicine indicates that the use of balanced crystalloids may be more beneficial than saline in caring for adult patients in the intensive care unit (ICU). The study included data from six randomized controlled trials involving a total of 34,685 participants. The findings suggest that balanced crystalloids may decrease in-hospital mortality compared to saline.

Advertisment

Benefits of Balanced Crystalloids

According to the review, the use of balanced crystalloids in the ICU setting was associated with a reduced risk of in-hospital mortality and decreased requirement for renal replacement therapy, which is often needed in cases of severe kidney failure. This implies that balanced crystalloids might be more protective to the kidneys than saline. It is notable that this evidence was of moderate certainty, indicating a reasonable level of confidence in these findings.

Special Consideration for Patients with Traumatic Brain Injury

Advertisment

However, the review also revealed that in patients with traumatic brain injury, the use of balanced crystalloids might lead to an increased risk of mortality. This suggests that while balanced crystalloids may generally be beneficial, their use should be carefully considered in certain patient populations, such as those with traumatic brain injuries. The reasons for this increased risk in this specific population are not yet clear and require further investigation.

Insights from Additional Sources

Further insights from other sources also reinforce the potential benefits of using balanced crystalloids. In addition to the reduced in-hospital mortality and decreased need for renal replacement therapy, balanced crystalloids are also associated with preventing adverse outcomes such as acute kidney injury and major adverse kidney events. These findings highlight the importance of personalized medicine and tailoring treatment strategies to individual patient needs.

Advertisment

Ties to the Pharmaceutical Industry

While the review presents promising findings, it's also important to consider the potential for bias. Some authors of the review disclosed ties to the pharmaceutical industry. Although this doesn't invalidate the findings, it's crucial for readers to be aware of these potential conflicts of interest when interpreting the results.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the use of balanced crystalloids in the ICU could potentially decrease in-hospital mortality and reduce the need for renal replacement therapy compared to saline. However, in patients with traumatic brain injury, their use should be carefully considered due to the potential increased risk of mortality. As always, these decisions should be made on a case-by-case basis, taking into account the individual patient's condition and needs.

Advertisment
Chat with Dr. Medriva !