Advertisment

Overtreatment in Maternity Care: A Global Concern

author-image
Anthony Raphael
New Update
NULL

Overtreatment in Maternity Care: A Global Concern

Advertisment

A recent analysis published in the British Medical Journal underscores a significant concern in the world of maternity care: overtreatment. The study reveals that a considerable proportion of women receiving treatment during childbirth, such as oxytocin or cesarean sections, may not actually need it. This global prevalence of overtreatment has grown to alarming proportions, with researchers stressing that many women do not require the treatment they receive.

Advertisment

Understanding Overtreatment

Overtreatment refers to the provision of medical services that are unnecessary or that pose more harm than benefit to the patient. The study, which has drawn considerable attention, shows that between 30-90% of first-time mothers receive medical augmentation with oxytocin to boost contractions, a treatment that many may not need. Moreover, cesarean birth rates are rising fast, with an average of 21% of women giving birth through cesarean sections, a number expected to rise to over 28% by 2030.

The Risks of Unnecessary Cesarean Sections and Oxytocin

Advertisment

The analysis does more than just highlight the prevalence of overtreatment; it also sheds light on the risks associated with unnecessary cesarean sections and the use of oxytocin. Cesarean sections, while lifesaving when necessary, can pose significant risks, especially in sub-Saharan African countries. Complications can lead to long-term health issues for both mother and baby.

As for oxytocin, the lack of comprehensive research into its effectiveness and potential risks is concerning. Some studies suggest that the drug, used to stimulate contractions, can result in insufficient blood flow through the umbilical cord, leading to stillbirths and brain damage in the baby. This alarming revelation points to a disconnect between best knowledge and practice, with cultural and habitual practices likely contributing to the large discrepancy between research and treatment received.

Global Disparities and Societal Factors

Advertisment

The global disparity in maternity care is starkly apparent, as countries like Afghanistan face high maternal mortality rates due to restrictive traditional customs, political upheaval, economic woes, and lack of access to medical care. In 2020, the maternal mortality ratio in the country was 620 deaths per 100,000 live births, a number that has seen a slight increase under Taliban rule.

Marketing and Misinformation

Further complicating the issue of overtreatment is the fact that feminist narratives are often hijacked to market medical tests not backed by evidence, leading to overdiagnosis and overtreatment. Tests like the AMH test and breast density notification are promoted to asymptomatic healthy women, despite the lack of reliable evidence and potential harm. Such practices underscore the need for transparency, balanced information, and greater scrutiny of conflicts of interest in health advocacy.

The Way Forward: An Evidence-Based Approach

The researchers call for updated clinical guidelines, encouraging a more evidence-based approach to maternity care. Such an approach could ensure a safe and supportive environment for childbirth globally, minimizing the risks of overtreatment. It is crucial that healthcare providers, policymakers, and patients alike become aware of this issue, promoting an environment where evidence-based practices are not the exception, but the norm.

Advertisment
Chat with Dr. Medriva !